Research and reports
Does an online review of your business look suspicious? If you don’t remember the customer or the interaction, you might be dealing with a fake online review.
Say you're faced with the Google review above, but the details don't add up. Firstly, you don’t remember a customer raising these issues recently. Come to think of it, there was no 29 February this year – and worse, you don’t even have a halloumi burger on the menu. You’re probably looking at a fake online review.
Word of mouth has always held huge power. A customer recommending your services to a friend or family member often holds more sway than any of your marketing materials.
The flipside? Customers sharing negative experiences can really harm your business, unless you take steps to make it right.
In the real world, the impact of baseless word of mouth is limited to one person’s social circle. But an anonymised, digital world opens up the opportunity for fake experiences to be shared with huge numbers of potential customers.
In June 2021 the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), the government’s competition regulator, opened an investigation into Amazon and Google. The CMA suggests that the internet giants may have broken consumer law by not taking enough action to protect shoppers from fake online reviews.
And in July 2021, the BBC reported on government proposals to make it illegal to pay someone to write (or host) a fake review.
So, the government accepts that fake online reviews are a problem, but their investigation is largely concerned with protecting consumers from fake positive reviews that fool people into buying a product. What about protecting businesses themselves from fake negative reviews?
Unfortunately, businesses have to deal with this problem on their own. Take the example of Blackpool restaurateur Steve Hoddy, who successfully took an online troll to court for malicious falsehood. The troll was ordered to pay £7,455 in compensation.
Before Hoddy got to the point of suing the fake reviewer, though, he’d already directly confronted him and managed to get Tripadvisor to remove the offending reviews.
Hoddy had an advantage considering he studied law at university. But even if you don’t know the legal ins-and-outs, you can still tackle fake online reviews armed with these top tips.
You should respond to a negative review whether it’s genuine or fake, but the tone of your response will differ depending on its authenticity.
How can you tell fake reviews apart?
To back this last point up, a 2011 study by Cornell University revealed that truthful hotel reviews are “more likely to use concrete words relating to the hotel, like bathroom, check-in or price.
"Deceivers do more to set the scene, using words like vacation, business trip or my husband.”
Fake reviews also use more verbs than nouns and more first-person pronouns like I and me.
Whether they’re positive or negative, responding to reviews lets you tell your side of the story. And if you’re setting the record straight when responding to a fake one, you can highlight its lack of authenticity in your response.
Pick up on the inaccurate details, or the more absurd ones. For instance, restaurateur Steve Hoddy’s troll suggested that “the owner glares at you weirdly”, so Hoddy countered by replying that he’d never dream of doing so.
Your response could even end up holding more influence than the review itself in the eyes of potential customers.
Suggest that you don’t have any record of the interaction and that you’re open to investigating. It’s important to be professional, so don’t be tempted to match the insults and tone of the fake review. Be brief, be polite, but be prepared to defend yourself too.
Your loyal customers know the real you, so being transparent about the fake review can be a great strategy.
If you politely call out the review on your social media platforms, using humour or sarcasm, you’re sending out the message that it’s nothing to worry about.
And asking for real reviews from customers can help make the fake ones less visible, as these reviews will show at the top. Find out how to get more Google reviews.
Unfortunately, the online giants don’t always make this easy. The platforms will usually give you the option to report a review for violating their policies, but it can be difficult for you to prove that the reviewer isn’t a genuine customer.
On Google and Facebook, the option to report the review is present on the post itself. Tripadvisor gives you the ability to manage reviews through your business’s account. Other platforms will give you similar options, so have a look at their help pages if you’re not sure.
You can ask your loyal customers to flag the review too, to make the problem more visible.
The platforms usually give you the option to escalate the issue. On Google, for example, you can log in to your Google Business Profile to manage your review removal requests. You’ll see details for contacting Google if you need more help.
The platforms might still ultimately decide that certain reviews don’t go against their guidelines. If that’s the case, your response is the most important weapon in fighting fake information.
Finally, be sure to keep an eye on all the feedback that you get about your business. Responding in a timely way helps you show that you take all feedback seriously, even if some of it is inauthentic.
You should be able to switch on notifications in your accounts across the various platforms. Do it on Google by signing into your Business Profile and going to Settings (here’s how to manage your notifications).
If you use other platforms, search their help pages to find out how to get notifications.
Have you ever had to deal with fake online reviews? Let us know in the comments below.
Sam has more than 10 years of experience in writing for financial services. He specialises in illuminating complicated topics, from IR35 to ISAs, and identifying emerging trends that audiences want to know about. Sam spent five years at Simply Business, where he was Senior Copywriter.
We create this content for general information purposes and it should not be taken as advice. Always take professional advice. Read our full disclaimer
6th Floor99 Gresham StreetLondonEC2V 7NG
Sol House29 St Katherine's StreetNorthamptonNN1 2QZ
© Copyright 2023 Simply Business. All Rights Reserved. Simply Business is a trading name of Xbridge Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (Financial Services Registration No: 313348). Xbridge Limited (No: 3967717) has its registered office at 6th Floor, 99 Gresham Street, London, EC2V 7NG.